Although older adults use the lion’s share of health care
services, treatment is often geared toward younger patients. More
positive eldercare focuses on the benefits of aging.
People over age 65 occupy about 50 percent of all
hospital beds, represent 25 percent of all physician office visits and
consume about 60 percent of all health care dollars. For these reasons,
quality eldercare should be seen as a major initiative of health care
providers.
Yet, according to Patricia Franklin, program manager at
the American Academy of Nursing Coordinating Center, less than one-third
of baccalaureate-level nursing programs had even one geriatric nursing
faculty member in 2006. In addition, older patients are often treated
less aggressively or in ways that are appropriate for younger patients.
Health care institutions must better accommodate these elders; one way
is to use an approach that focuses on the strengths of aging rather than
its downsides.
Ageism Negatively Impacts Eldercare
Ageism remains rampant in our culture and a significant
barrier to quality eldercare. Sharon Inouye, M.D., says, “Time and again
I saw older people (usually over 70) admitted to the hospital for acute
problems and then, almost invariably, these people would do very poorly.
I asked myself, ‘What is it that we are doing that causes hospital care
to become almost toxic for an older person?’” (Henry and Henry 2007).
She found that treatment practices often are based on
assumptions of younger patient protocols and frequently performed more
for staff convenience rather than on clear medical or clinical
indicators. The Hospital Elder Life Program (HELP) she developed at Yale
University School of Medicine and tested at Yale-New Haven Hospital
addresses six risk factors for delirium in older people. Among the
notable outcomes is a significant reduction in the development of
delirium and functional decline. More than 50 health care organizations
nationally have adopted HELP.
A 2003 report by the Alliance for Aging Research
outlines five key dimensions of ageist bias in health care:
- Many health care professionals do not receive enough
geriatric training to properly care for older patients.
- Older patients are less likely than younger people to receive
preventive care.
- Older patients are less likely to be tested or screened for diseases
and other health problems.
- Proven medical interventions for older patients are often ignored,
leading to inappropriate or incomplete treatment.
- Older people are consistently excluded from clinical trials, although
they are the largest users of approved drugs.
Notes Neal Flomenbaum, M.D., F.C.A.P., F.A.E.P., of New
York-Presbyterian Hospital, who heads the first geriatric emergency
medicine fellowship, “People at the extremes of age--very old, neonates
and infants--present with significant illnesses, but signs and symptoms
may not be consistent with the illness’s seriousness” (Henry and Henry
2007). The aging process affects an older person’s ability to respond to
acute medical and physical changes.
Elaine Gould, M.S.W., director of programs at the
Hartford Institute for Geriatric Nurses, reminds us, “Older adults are
the core business of health care.” Therefore, health care workers can’t
afford to cling to unfounded myths about aging (see table 1
below).
Combating Pervasive Stereotypes
Unfortunately, many of these myths tend to become
self-fulfilling prophecies on the part of young and old alike. Joseph
Heller once said, “Be careful how you interpret the world; it is like
that.” Cultural ageism creates lifelong attitudes leading to negative
behaviors on the part of elders and the health care providers who serve
them.
Fortunately, a growing amount of research suggests the
opposite can also be true. In his book, What Are Old People For?,
Bill Thomas, M.D., founder of the Eden Alternative movement, documents a
transformational approach to elderhood and eldercare. It can be a time
of ripening, of reflecting upon one’s life experiences and of capturing
periods of richness that help formulate a sense of one’s life purpose
and legacy (Thomas 2004).
Gerotranscendence, a term coined by
gerontologist Lars Tornstam, Ph.D., instructor of social gerontology at
Uppsala University in Sweden, means elders rising above the cultural
demands of adulthood and moving in the direction of maturation,
wisdom and spiritual growth. The concept of gerotranscendence was based
on qualitative and quantitative research from 1990 involving interviews
and surveys with thousands of older adults ages 65 to 104 (Tornstam
2005). These elder characteristics and strengths are born out by many of
the health care providers interviewed for our books.
In his chapter in Religion, Spirituality and Aging,
Eugene Bianchi, Ph.D., reports the results of interviews with more than
100 creative elders. Their strengths compare quite favorably with the
research of Tornstam, as highlighted in table 2
below.
Tapping Personal Strengths
Strengths-based care management is based on the premise
that elders have a tremendous capacity for continued growth and autonomy
and provides techniques and tools to help care managers focus on a
patient’s strengths and abilities instead of their pathology, illness or
problem. Patients are viewed as competent and able to participate in the
planning and delivery processes of the care plan, thus gaining a sense
of control over their lives.
When Longmont (Colo.) Memorial Hospital opened a senior
wellness center, the director formed an advisory group of elders named
“the wise ones.” Based on their input, traditional wellness classes and
activities gave way to more complementary and alternative healing
modalities. Today the PrestigePlus Center offers a wide array of healing
practices, including tai chi, reminiscence classes, reiki, healing touch
acupuncture and Chinese herbal medicine; 70 percent of the clients are
over 60.
Granted, not all aging is positive. Many elders
encounter health challenges from arthritis to diminished mobility. They
often experience financial difficulties, cognitive decline and loss of
family and friends. However, when we focus on a person’s strengths,
problems may diminish somewhat. It is also true that many elders have
more time to volunteer, bestowing blessings on others as well as
themselves. Former president Jimmy and first lady Rosalyn Carter are
examples of life expansion, not diminishment.
In addition, while we believe the seed of growth toward
maturity and gerotranscendence exists in all people, it may never
germinate for some because of social, psychological and environmental
dynamics. Some elders limp grumpy, stubborn, narrow-minded and decrepit
to death’s door. Others display flickers of growth and, if observed over
a longer period of time, show flashes of the attributes of holistic
aging.
Not Just Older Adults
Elders are not just older adults any more than children
are young adults. “Today we have a foundational understanding of what it
means to age, and it needs to be shared with almost all caregivers,”
states Sarah Kagan, Ph.D., R.N., gerontological associate professor at
the University of Pennsylvania School of Nursing. This holds true not
only for the clinical issues surrounding the aging process, but for the
social, psychological and spiritual dimensions of elderhood; not just to
promote competence but because there is no “we and they.” Physicians and
nurses are both elder caretakers and future elders. Therefore,
attention to clinical indicators is not enough. It becomes imperative to
learn as much as possible about holistic aging.